The title of Tim Pawlenty’s ad in Iowa should be
‘smell test’ – because it doesn’t pass it. The Minnesota Tim
Pawlenty
left behind wasn’t nearly as rosy as he’d like voters in Iowa to
believe. Tim Pawlenty left Minnesota with a projected $6.2
billion
deficit, higher property taxes, higher tuition rates and all this after
slashing spending on critical services for education and seniors.
And,
at the end of Pawlenty’s tenure health care costs for families had
spiked and the number of uninsured had increased. If Tim Pawlenty
is
looking for a resume item to make the case for why he should be
president he should look beyond his failed tenure as Governor of
Minnesota.
Please see below for a fact check of Tim Pawlenty’s new campaign
ad…
PAWLENTY RHETORIC: “I reduced
spending in real terms for the first time.”
REALITY: PAWLENTY ONLY CUT SPENDING BY
SHIFTING FUNDS FROM SCHOOLS, USING ACCOUNTING GIMMICKS, AND TAKING
FEDERAL DOLLARS
Pawlenty
“Balanced Each Two-Year State Budget” But “Critics There Say They Stem
From Short-Term Funding Maneuvers That Were Used During His Tenure To
Patch Over Shortfalls—And To Put Off Tough Decisions To Align
Minnesota's Tax Base With Its Government Spending.” [Wall Street
Journal,
6/2/11]
Minnesota
Management And Budget Official Said Pawlenty Did Lower Spending In Real
Terms For In 2010, But “Said… Spending That Year Would Have Looked
Different If The State Had Not Put Off Education Payments And Taken
Billions From The Federal Government.” [Wall Street Journal,
6/2/11]
Pawlenty
Balanced The Minnesota Budget With “Accounting Tricks, A Well-Timed
Infusion Of Stimulus Money From Washington And Word Games.” [Associated
Press,
5/25/11]
REALITY: PAWLENTY WAS NOT THE FIRST TO
CUT SPENDING IN “REAL TERMS”
Politifact: Pawlenty’s Claim That He “Cut Spending In Real Terms For
The First Time In 150 Years” Is “Barely True.” [Politifact,
4/12/11]
· Politifact:
The 2010-2011 Budget Cycle Marked The First Time The Biennium Budget
Was Cut, But The Annual Budget Was Also Cut In 2009, 2004, 1986 And
1983. [Politifact,
4/12/11]
Politifact:
“We Don't Have 150 Years Of Budget Data To Check. We Only Found Data
Back To 1960, And Pawlenty's Campaign Provided No Data To Back Up The
Claim Covering The 100 Years Previous When We Asked For It.”
[Politifact,
4/12/11]
PAWLENTY RHETORIC: “I… passed
health care reform the right way.”
REALITY: UNDER PAWLENTY, THE NUMBER OF
UNINSURED MINNESOTANS ROSE AND HEALTH CARE COSTS FOR FAMILIES INCREASED
2009:
9 Percent Of Minnesotans Were Uninsured. “In 2009, approximately 9.0
percent of Minnesotans, or about 478,000 people, did not have health
insurance coverage.” [Minnesota Department of Health Fact Sheet,
January 2011]
· 2002: 6.2
Percent Of Minnesotans Were Uninsured. [Minnesota Department of
Health, Issue Brief,
August 2006]
Families
USA Report: “Family Health Care Premiums Rose An Estimated 4.3 Times
Faster Than Earnings For Minnesota’s Workers From 2000 To 2007.” [Press
Release, FamiliesUSA,
9/17/08]
REALITY: PAWLENTY DID NOT SAVE MINNESOTA MUCH IN HEALTH CARE COSTS
Star Tribune
Editorial: Under Pawlenty “Only Modest Steps Toward Cost-Containing
Health Care Improvement Occurred… While The Cuts He Made In Health
Insurance Eligibility And A Host Of Other Social Programs Added To The
Misery Of The Poor And Vulnerable.” [Star Tribune, Editorial,
3/22/11]
Pawlenty
“Has Been Touting The Success Of Minnesota's Home-Grown Health Reforms”
But “Some Health Care Observers Believe It's A Stretch To Say That
Minnesota's Experiments Have Had Much Of An Effect On Costs.”
[Minnesota Public Radio,
2/8/11]
REALITY: PAWLENTY RELIED ON FEDERAL DOLLARS TO FUND HEALTH PROGRAMS
Pawlenty
“Decided To Accept About $260 Million In Federal Medical Assistance Aid
After Directing State Agencies To Avoid Some Federal Grants Associated
With The Health Care Overhaul.” [Associated Press, 9/7/10]
Pawlenty’s Proposed Budget Included $387 Million In Medicaid Funds From
The Stimulus. [Hot Dish Politics blog, Star Tribune,
2/16/10]
Pawlenty
“Will Accept Federal Assistance Under The Democrats’ Health Reform Law
After All” Because Minnesota’s “Management and Budget Office Was One Of
700 New Organizations That Signed Up For The Early Retiree Reinsurance
Program, A $5 Billion Program That Helps Pay For The Insurance Costs Of
Retirees Between The Ages Of 55 And 64.” [Politico,
10/29/10]